February
14, 2008
Instructions
on how to Ignore Boundary Commission Report
"In
this report, we propose a total of 83 electoral districts,
with a provincial quotient of 49,560. We continue to propose
a reduction of one electoral district in each of the North
and the Cariboo-Thompson regions, but propose that the number
of electoral districts in the Columbia-Kootenay region stay
the same and that six electoral districts be added in urban
regions."
Electoral Boundaries Commission, amended
report, p. 1 (pdf page 11)
The Boundary
Commission didn't quite refuse to bow to the bullying
tactics of the Campbell government. Bill 39 which would have
required the Commission to preserve unequal (by population)
representation in select areas of the province was abandoned
when opposed by the NDP, but the Campbell government announced
that it would not implement recommendations of the Commission
if it failed to accommodate the essence of the abandoned legislation.
If the Campbell government carries through on that threat
it could put the legitimacy of the May 12, 2009 election in
question.
The Commission
provided the Campbell government with precise instructions
on how to ignore its report and implement new boundaries as
if Bill 39 passed. Appendix P of its amended report provides
maps of the boundaries for eight electoral districts in the
North and five in the Cariboo-Thompson and the reasoning for
them, as they would have been required to do under Bill 39.
The Commission wrote: "In the event that the legislature
accepts our proposals in the other 10 regions, but decides
to proceed with alterations to restore the number of electoral
districts in these two regions, the maps contained in Appendix
P may provide assistance to the legislature when drawing the
boundaries for these two regions." In other words, the
Commission wouldn't violate what it saw as its legal responsibilities
but it has provided the legislature with instructions on how
to begin a process that may end in the Supreme Court of Canada.
|