Strategic Thoughts

bannerspacerAbout Me | Mail Me | Linksbannerspacer2

August 12, 2005

Two Ministers, Two Responses

Many environmentalists were delighted when Premier Campbell repented and reinstated the Ministry of the Environment. The new minister, Barry Penner, said during an interview on the Rafe Mair show that he would defend the environment rather than front for industry. Where has he been since then? On August 10th the Ministry of the Environment issued an "information bulletin" with respect to CN Rail's August 5th chemical spill in the Cheakamus River. That is the only item with respect to the environmental damage that can be found on the government website, and that item is not included on the top page. Penner is not quoted or mentioned in the bulletin. Why hasn't he visited the site, witnessed the fish kill and spoken to those whose well water may be contaminated?

CN also had a serious spill in Lake Wabamun just outside Edmonton . The Alberta government's website contains pages of information on the spill, and its Minister of the Environment has been in the news regularly expressing his outrage with CN and his intent to hold it responsible to the full extent of the law.

It is true that the spill in Alberta is potentially far more dangerous; a known carcinogen was dumped in lake water used by residents for showers and dish washing. CN is alleged to have delayed its report, as well as initially misreporting the nature of the contaminant. Nevertheless, both governments are dealing with the transport of dangerous substances by the railway. Of course in BC, CN is a major contributor to the BC Liberals who recently returned the favour by giving it BC Rail. In Alberta a bold Minister has let the public know that the government will hold CN to account. In BC a rookie Minister has disappeared and his Ministry put out a bulletin a week late emphasizing the role of the federal government. If the Cheakamus spill indicates what we can expect of Penner, a lot of trouble lies ahead.

 

About Me | Mail Me | Navigation | Top
© 2005 David D. Schreck. All Rights Reserved.