July
9, 2004
Population
Loss, Polls and Credibility
There
was a net outflow of British Columbians to other provinces
in the first quarter of 2004. You might not know that from
reading the local print media, and you certainly wouldn't
know it from the government website.
Between
January 1, 2004, and March 31, 2004, 11,554 people moved to
BC from other provinces while 11,804 moved out of BC to other
parts of Canada for net
negative interprovincial migration of 250. That
warrants attention because part of the "BC has turned
the corner" mantra of the Campbell government was to
shout about net positive interprovincial migration in the
fourth quarter of 2003. Now they are ignoring recent interprovincial
migration and focusing on net migration from all sources,
which was positive 7,417; however, net migration from all
sources has been positive in BC for decades.
There
is a government
website which cherry picks positive economic news. It
only refers to the 7,417 first quarter 2004 total results
and to the fourth quarter 2003 interprovincial results but
fails to mention that BC had net negative introprovincial
migration in the first quarter of 2004. BC's
population growth rate has fallen to 0.8%, below the national
average of 0.9%. It fluctuated between 1.0% and 3.0% for most
of the 1970s, 80s and 90s. That is also not obvious from reading
the Campbell government's numbers. The point is that it
is not possible to believe what the government says as it
struggles to regain credibility. It could start by telling
the whole truth.
On July
8th the Mustel
Group and Ipsos-Reid
both released their provincial polling results from samples
taken in the first week of July. The Mustel Group has the
NDP at 45%, the Campbell Liberals at 33% and the Greens at
14%. Ipsos-Reid has the NDP at 38%, the Campbell Liberals
at 37% and the Greens at 18%. The Mustel Group has Campbell's
disapproval rating at 60%; Ipsos-Reid has it at 62%. Other
than for Campbell's disapproval rating, the difference between
the two polling firms is greater in July than it has been
in years, but both show a consistent trend of the Liberals
falling and the NDP rising.
Ipsos-Reid
provides detailed tables of its results. They show the Greens
strongest on Vancouver Island-Coast with 22%. That's where
the Campbell Liberals have 24% and the NDP 49%.
There
may be a relation between the polling results and the problem
the Campbell government has with its credibility.
|