March
25, 2004
Failed
Regionalization Fails Children
The new
Minister of Children and Family Development, Christy Clark,
is strangely silent on the cancellation of one of her ministry's
major initiatives, regionalization of child protection. Judith
Lavoie of the Times Colonist broke the story that the planning
committees have been disbanded and any attempt to shift services
to regional authorities will be delayed until fiscal year
2006-07 at the earliest. The news came from a memo to staff
from the Deputy Minister. Nothing has been posted on the Ministry's
website and no news release has come out of government on
yet another major setback.
On March
24, 2003, in his last estimates debate, her predecessor, Gordon
Hogg, said:
"As
members know, Children and Family Development is moving
toward a five-region governance model that reflects the
boundaries of the five health districts. Interim CEOs and
regional planning committees were appointed last year, and
extensive community consultations have been going on for
months. Most of the planning committees are now writing
their reports for submission in the coming weeks. The next
step will be the appointment of interim authorities and
boards. This will take us into a period of comanagement
that will last until the interim boards have met all the
readiness criteria and can give way to permanent authorities
that take on responsibility for service delivery. That was
originally scheduled for April of 2004 but may be as early
as next fall for one or two of those regions."
Many may
find it strange that a project that was set to go, that had
hired interim CEOs, is suddenly put on the back burner. The
reason lies, at least in part, on financial chaos. On February
6, 2004, the Ministry issued a news
release titled "Ministry Upgrading Financial Management".
The title is somewhat ironic in light of the audit on how
$400,000 was written off without proper authority. Amongst
the changes announced in the release was "Grants to support
transition planning for regional and community governance
are being reviewed. Audits of grants to aboriginal planning
committees will begin immediately and will focus on recommendations
to improve future practice."
The government
that campaigned on the basis of being good managers is proving
itself to be incompetent. Don't hold your breath waiting for
an admission of how much was wasted on the failed planning
exercise; the government might not be able to suppress information
on financial irregularities that no doubt contributed to the
cancellation of regionalization.
The Ministry's
website still boasts a picture of Clark being sworn in. It
is time to update it with some hard information:
- What
is happening to the failed regionalization initiative?
- How
much did it cost?
- What
is the impact on children at risk?
- Has
the elimination of practice audits lowered standards?
- With
no regional authorities to certify, will practice audits
be restored?
- Why
has the government that campaigned on a promise to bring
stability to the Ministry, created chaos?
Read,
or better yet view, estimates debate for March 24th to
hear Christy Clark's arrogant responses to the NDP's Jenny
Kwan, as she confidently held her to account. Clark repeatedly
dismissed Kwan's questions with high school debating points
as if she didn't have to be accountable. Clark didn't appear
to understand that she is accountable for hundreds of millions
of tax dollars, and it is not good enough to say that questions
should have been asked at some other time. Her attitude is
one of the reasons for their dramatic decline in the polls.
It is unfortunate that thousands of children who depend on
the Ministry can fall victim to that arrogant attitude.
|