August
12, 2003
Disability
Review Cost 3 Times the "Savings"
The
Campbell government spent over $3 million to harass
19,000 people with disabilities, and found 400 people
who may have their benefits cut. The government news
release falsely claimed that "As a result of
the review, there is now about $8 million a year that
can be spent on new clients who are eligible for persons
with disabilities assistance." If there is any
"savings" as a result of the $3 million "review",
it is little more than a third of the cost of the review
or less than a fifth of the amount of "savings"
claimed by government.
Months
after the "review"
was to be complete, in the middle of August the news
release from the Minister of Human Resources, Murray
Coell, announced that there are "400 people who
had their disability designation rescinded because they
did not meet the medical requirements or chose not to
return their forms. In addition, 695 cases were closed
because individuals' financial circumstances had changed".
The news release did not say that any of the 695 cases
were being charged with fraud; in other words, the 695
cases whose financial circumstances had changed would
have reported those changes in the normal course of
events with or without the $3 million review.
The
disability review caused enormous anxiety for 19,000
"clients", and at least one possible suicide
according to a coroner's report. The government finally
backed down and eliminated the requirement for 5,000
people who were mentally ill. The grand result of putting
people through the "review" is that 400 people
may yet submit their paperwork late or appeal the decision
to reduce their benefits; hopefully none will take destructive
actions when their benefits are reduced from a
maximum of $786.42 for a single disabled person
to a maximum of $510.00
for an employable person. The annual "savings"
to the government from reducing benefits for 400 people
by $276.42 per month is $1,326,816 - about one third
of the cost of the review. The consequences for
the 400 people (who at the very least are marginally
disabled) of having their income cut by 35% could be
catastrophic.
According
to the government's news release "Clients who wish
to appeal the decision have 20 business days from the
date of notification to inform the ministry of their
intent to appeal and provide new information for their
case." The Campbell government has eliminated funding
for many of the organizations that previously assisted
people who have trouble coping on their own, but the
BC Coalition
of People with Disabilities is one organization
that will no doubt do all it can to help the victims
of Campbell's crackdown.
Only
the government knows exactly who the 400 people are
who will receive cuts of $276 per month. The Campbell
government is spending many thousands of dollars on
a poorly designed "exit
survey" that attempts to support claims that
most people are leaving welfare for work; the suggestion
is that more people are leaving welfare for work now
than in the past although 66% did not respond to the
latest "survey". After spending $3 million
to find and cut the benefits for 400 people, the least
the Campbell government can do is to put some effort
into monitoring and reporting on what happens to those
400 people after their benefits are cut by 35%.