Like
most folks, I have a hard time wrapping my mind around
the staggeringly large sums that are used in the world
of government and business finance these days. The Economist
magazine reported this week that "AOL Time Warner
is to write off as much as $60 billion in the first quarter
thanks to new rules over accounting for 'goodwill'."
Those are US dollars, so the potential "write off"
is CAN $96 billion, or about enough money to pay for all
BC provincial health expenditures for about 10 years.
Comparisons
help to create some kind of understandable perspective
when the numbers are beyond ordinary experience. There
are two useful hints for dealing with big numbers. First,
determine whether the number applies only once or whether
it goes on year after year. Second, compare it to something
else, like to the BC per person cost by dividing it by
4 million.
Try
the fast ferry fiasco as an example. If every penny spent
on the fast ferries was a loss, then it would be equal
to about a $100 bill for every person in the province.
That is bad, but is it better or worse than giving the
top 8,000 income earners in BC a combined total of over
$200 million in tax cuts or an amount equal to $50 for
every person in the province - not just one time, but
forever - year after year after year?
While
the AOL Time Warner write off tops the list, one
publication estimates that the new US accounting rule
dealing with overvalued assets will require the write
off of US $1.86 trillion.
Keep
that figure in mind the next time you hear someone say
government should behave just like business. Of course,
that figure is so enormous it is like trying to understand
the distance to the nearest star. Some local media are
criticizing the former government for spending $16 million
on buses so as to try to have cleaner air. Even if all
of that spending were a loss, it would equal $4 for each
person in the province, or relative to the US corporate
write downs, it would equal less than 0.001 of one percent.
Still a lot of money in your pocket or mine, but a pittance
relative to the amounts thrown around (and lost) in the
corporate world every day.
None
of this is to excuse government errors, but the corporate
apologists that currently rule BC ought to keep these
comparisons in mind as their errors start to be tallied.